Thursday, April 26, 2007

The Great Snail Race, Part VI: The First Debate

1. Hilary is about as electrifying a speaker as John Kerry is. She does better when she sounds conversational, but when she tried to tell a touching story about Columbine, her pauses were excessively long.

2. When Barack listens to a question, he shakes his head like he has Alzheimer's if he wants to indicate sympathy for the question's concerns.


3. I'm surprised to hear Bill Richardson say he would vote against funding the troops. Richardson creates some space between himself and Clinton when he says he would withdraw all "residual" troops by the end of the year. Clinton has said she will "end the war," but on other occasions she has committed keeping residual troops there.


4. Chris Dodd reminds me of an anchor man on a local news channel. Or someone who makes public service announcements. I guess it's the deep voice and the hair.


5. Mike Gravel's campaign bumper sticker is "I'm mad." (Both readings apply.) He claims some of the other candidates frighten him. He indirectly indicts John Edwards for his comment that "nothing is off the table" with regard to Iraq, which Gravel suggests as code for a nuclear threat, but he doesn't use Edwards's name, even when Brian gives him a chance to. Gravel then insults Biden as having "a certain arrogance." Gravel's here to remind us what real town hall meetings are like. When we go a long time without hearing from Gravel again, I wonder if Brian's punished him for going off. Gravel finally gets a chance and tells everybody he is angry because he feels like he's being treated like a potted plant even though he is the "senior statesman" of the group.


6. When asked, "What would you consider to be a mission-complete status in Iraq?" Barack doesn't answer the question.


7. I like the fact that Hilary says, "I think that Barack is right," especially since the theme is working together on ending the war in Iraq. Could this be a president-vice-president pairing? Barack later refers to Hilary by her first name.


8. I have yet to see much of a sense of humor in John Edwards—not the most important quality in a President, but it would give him more of the common touch.


9. Why is Brian Williams asking about hedge funds? What are hedge funds? Who cares about them?


10. I find myself listening to the first 15 seconds of each answer. I notice this when Bill Richardson is talking.


11. Biden has the best funny moment, when he delivers a one-word answer to the question about his "uncontrolled verbosity."


12. Edwards tries hard to emote compassion. Obama, by contrast, comes off as "considerate."


13. Bill Richardson is the NRA's favorite candidate, Republican or Democrat—that's a good note, Brian. Thanks. Bill also has the longest ears.


14. Edwards, Obama and Clinton have not had a gun in their house as an adult. That's the difference between the first and third tier candidates.


15. Edwards uses his hands more than anybody else does.


16. Bill is the first candidate who seems to be reading from notecards while giving an answer (about how he's going to pay for universal medical care without raising taxes). Maybe it's just a tic, though.


17. Edwards says his mistake was misjudging the Iraq War vote and the lesson he has learned from the experience is to trust his judgment more (wha?).


18. My favorite line of the night? Edwards in response to a question about the environment: "We ought to ask Americans to be patriotic about something other than war. We ought to ask them to conserve."


19. Richardson is most guilty of crossing over the time limits without wrapping up.


20. Biden seems to be getting more questions than Edwards is.


21. Kucinich produces a prop: a pocket copy of the Constitution. This is a perfect example of Kucinich's poor leadership skills. He uses the pocket Constitution to argue that Cheney should be impeached. Fine. Impeach him. But why do you need to hold up a pocket Constitution to make the point?


22. I'm giving the most eye-rolls to Richardson for pointless blather (which may just mean I'm actually trying to listen to his pointless blather).


23. Dennis and Obama are fighting. Dennis disputes Barack's assertion that no one disputes the fact that Iran is developing nuclear weapons.


24. When asked who his moral leader is, Edwards pauses for a long time-. I imagine he's debating whether or not to name Jesus Christ. He begins by saying, "I don't think I could identify one person that I consider to be my moral leader." Then goes to ,"My Lord is important to me. I go to him in prayer everyday to ask for both forgiveness and counsel." And then picks up his wife "the finest human being I've ever known" and ends with his dad.

3 comments:

ervierto said...

Hmmm... From NPR's summary clips, I got the impression that Edwards is going to be hard-pressed to overcome the pretty-boy image created by his $400 haircuts charged to the campaign (I don't care how he spends his campaign money, but I sure bet I could get him a better deal...). I also thought about the Clinton-Obama ticket (or Obama-Clinton) listening to their supposed camraderie. NPR also reported that Obama stopped by Clinton's green room before the debate, presumably to set the tone for their friendly banter. I think Kucinich is not a real candidate. I think he is there to shape the issues. Ditto for Dodd, MAD dude, and maybe Biden and Richardson as well. I'm sure there is plenty about Richardson I don't know, but all of the stuff I hear about him is bad. The NRA's favorite candidate? Yikes.

lfjackal said...

The two things that bothered me the most were Dodd's comment on gay marriage. He took me to the very edge when he began his response by saying that we should all put it in the context of our own children. But then he recited the standard safe statement that he was for civil unions but not marriage. It sounded a heckuva a lot to me like seperate but equal.

The other was the inability for anyone to say the obvious on gun control: A homicidal maniac was able to order at least one of his guns online and pick it up at a store like I could order a novel at Barnes and Noble. It's a way too easy to get a gun in this country. I'm a firm believer in the second amendment: We should all have the right to own Kentucky flintlock rifles and muskets.

I thought it was a horrible debate. The time would have been better served if each candidate had been given five minutes each to state their positions: 40 minutes. The remaining 50 minutes could then have been used to clarify and get specifics on those comments. Perhaps even a Simon Cowell-like figure could then comment on the emptiness of some statements and the validity and specificity of others.

I still prefer Gore to anyone on that stage and not just because of Inconvenient Truth. Also because of his stand on the war in 2003, and the description of him in Richard Clarke's book AGAINST ALL ENEMIES (which was actually when I first started liking him).

Anonymous said...

My spouse is running for mayor of Archer City. He is publishing positions each week in an ad (concerns about the water and roads in Our Fair City, oh yeah, sewage treatment, too) and has noticed that other candidated are taking out ads, too. So far, two guys interested in the city council seats and one for the school board have stated their interest in streets and water (and sewers), too. So far, the only hint of mud was from Boe (the other mayoral candidate)who pointed out that he has always lived here. Some of my friends think that is a definite minus, others point out that Boe hasn't spoken to them in ten years - until now. D is sending a letter to the high school seniors explaining how their vote can make a difference (really can - fewer than 150 people voted in the last mayoral race).It will be interesting.